The S corp vs. LLC question trips up a lot of owners because it compares two different things. An LLC is a legal structure you form with the state. An S corporation is a federal tax status you choose with the IRS. A Colorado LLC can stay taxed the default way, or it can elect to be taxed as an S corp.
So the real question is usually this, should your LLC keep its default tax treatment, or is your business profitable enough that an S corp election saves more than it costs? Here’s how I walk owners through it.
What an LLC Is
A limited liability company is a business entity created under state law. In Colorado, you form one by filing articles of organization with the Colorado Secretary of State.
The main benefit is liability protection, in general, the business’s debts and lawsuits stay with the business rather than your personal assets, as long as you keep business and personal finances separate. For contractors, an LLC works alongside your general liability insurance, not in place of it.
For federal taxes, an LLC has default treatment unless it elects otherwise. Under IRS rules, a single-member LLC is a “disregarded entity,” taxed much like a sole proprietorship, and an LLC with two or more members is taxed as a partnership. Either way, profits pass through to the owners’ personal returns.
The catch for profitable owners is self-employment tax. Under default treatment, an active owner generally pays self-employment tax on business earnings. The IRS sets the self-employment tax rate at 15.3%, 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare, with the Social Security portion applying up to an annual wage limit.
What an S Corp Is
An S corporation is a corporation, or an eligible entity such as an LLC, that elects to pass its income, losses, deductions and credits through to its owners for federal tax purposes. You make the election by filing Form 2553 with the IRS.
The IRS sets eligibility rules, including:
- It must be a domestic corporation or eligible entity
- No more than 100 shareholders
- Only one class of stock
- Shareholders generally can’t be partnerships, corporations or nonresident aliens
Timing matters. The IRS instructions for Form 2553 say to file no more than two months and 15 days after the start of the tax year you want the election to take effect, or at any time during the prior tax year.
S Corp vs. LLC: The Tax Difference That Matters Most
The main reason owners consider S corp status is how it changes payroll taxes.
In an S corp, an owner who works in the business is paid in two ways:
- A salary run through payroll, with Social Security and Medicare taxes withheld and matched.
- Distributions of remaining profit, which are generally not subject to those employment taxes.
The IRS requires the salary to be reasonable. Its guidance on S corporation compensation says an S corp must pay reasonable compensation to a shareholder-employee for their services before making non-wage distributions, and the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages if the salary is too low.
Here’s a simplified example. Say your electrical contracting business earns $150,000 in profit after expenses, and a reasonable salary for an owner who runs jobs and manages crews is $80,000. As an S corp, the remaining $70,000 could come out as distributions.
At the 15.3% rate, that’s roughly $10,700 that on paper would no longer face Social Security and Medicare tax.
The real number will be smaller once you subtract payroll costs, extra filings and accounting fees, and it shifts with other factors, such as how self-employment tax is calculated and the qualified business income deduction. Treat it as a starting point for a conversation, not a projected saving.

Side-by-Side Comparison
| LLC (default tax treatment) | LLC or corporation taxed as an S corp | |
| What it is | A legal entity formed under state law | A federal tax election |
| How profit is taxed | Passes through to owners’ personal returns | Passes through to owners’ personal returns |
| Owner payroll taxes | Self-employment tax on business earnings | Payroll taxes on salary, distributions generally not subject to employment taxes |
| Owner pay | Owner draws, no payroll required | Reasonable salary through payroll required |
| Ownership rules | Flexible, any number and type of members | Up to 100 eligible shareholders, one class of stock |
| Profit splits | Can be set in the operating agreement | Distributions follow ownership percentages |
| Paperwork | Simpler | Payroll filings, separate federal S corp return and more bookkeeping |
Colorado Points to Know Before Choosing
A few state-level details matter here:
- Formation. Colorado LLCs are formed with the Colorado Secretary of State. An S corp election doesn’t create a new entity, so a Colorado LLC electing S status keeps its LLC formation and state filings.
- State income tax filing. The Colorado Department of Revenue requires every partnership or S corporation doing business in Colorado to file Form DR 0106 and give each owner a Colorado K-1. Income generally passes through to the owners’ Colorado returns.
- SALT Parity election. Colorado lets partnerships and S corporations elect to pay Colorado income tax at the entity level, with owners receiving a credit for their share. Whether it helps depends on your situation, so it’s one more factor to model when comparing structures.
- Local requirements. Some Colorado cities have their own business licensing and tax filings, whichever federal tax treatment you choose.
When an S Corp Election May Make Sense
An S corp election is worth a closer look when:
- Your profit is steady and well above a reasonable salary for your role. The bigger the gap, the more there is to gain.
- You can pay yourself on a regular payroll. That means a payroll provider, quarterly filings and on-time deposits.
- Your bookkeeping is current and clean. S corps need clear records of salary, distributions and shareholder transactions. If yours aren’t there yet, catch-up and monthly bookkeeping comes first.
- Ownership is simple. One or a few U.S. owners with straightforward percentages.
For contractors, timing is a real question. A general contractor or roofing company with a strong, consistent year may benefit. A firm whose profit swings with the season still has to pay a reasonable salary in the lean months, which can strain cash.
When Staying a Default LLC May Be Better
Keeping default LLC tax treatment often makes more sense when:
- Profit is modest, so extra payroll and accounting costs could wipe out the savings
- Income is uneven or the business is still finding its footing
- You want profit splits that don’t match ownership, such as two partners in a building company who split profit based on who brings in the work
- You have owners who aren’t eligible S corp shareholders, such as another business entity
There’s no reward for choosing a structure early. Many owners start as an LLC and revisit the S corp election once profit is consistent.
How to Decide Between an S Corp and an LLC
I look at four things with owners before recommending a structure:
- Your expected profit for this year and next, not just last year
- A defensible reasonable salary for the work you do
- The added costs of payroll, filings and bookkeeping
- Your plans, such as adding partners, buying equipment or selling the business later
Then I run the numbers both ways. This is part of year-round tax planning, and it’s best done before the year starts or early enough to meet the Form 2553 deadline. I don’t prepare tax returns. I hand a clear plan to your tax preparer, who files based on the structure you’ve chosen.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice for your specific situation.
Get a Second Opinion on Your Structure
I’m Martha Hall, founder of Enlightened Advisory, and I help Colorado business owners plan their taxes all year instead of scrambling in April.
The right answer to S corp vs. LLC depends on your profit, your plans and your appetite for paperwork. Book a free consultation and we’ll run your numbers both ways.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can an LLC Be an S Corp?
Yes. An LLC can elect to be taxed as an S corporation by filing Form 2553, as long as it meets the IRS eligibility rules. It stays an LLC under Colorado law.
2. What Is the Biggest Disadvantage of an S Corp?
For many small businesses, it’s the added work and cost, running payroll for yourself, filing a separate federal return and keeping tighter records. You also have to pay a reasonable salary, even in a slower year.
3. What Is the Biggest Disadvantage of an LLC?
Under default tax treatment, active owners generally pay self-employment tax on their share of business earnings, which can add up as profit grows.
4. How Much Should I Pay Myself as an S Corp Owner?
There’s no single number. The IRS expects a reasonable salary for the work you do, and its guidance lists factors such as your training, duties, time spent on the business and what comparable businesses pay for similar services. Document how you set it.
5. Can I Switch from an LLC to an S Corp Later?
Yes. Many owners revisit the S corp vs. LLC decision once profit is steady and then file the election. Timing and paperwork matter, so plan the switch ahead of the tax year you want it to start.